Tristan Jarry Trade Grades: The trade market finally had its big shakeup with the Edmonton Oilers and Pittsburgh Penguins completing a blockbuster goaltender swap.
In a deal that speaks volumes about both teams’ immediate needs and long-term strategies, the Oilers acquired Tristan Jarry and forward Samuel Poulin in exchange for goaltender Stuart Skinner, defenseman Brett Kulak, and a 2029 second-round draft pick.
Table of Contents
🏒 Tristan Jarry Trade Grades: The Goaltending Gambit – Who Won the Oilers and Penguins Deal?
This wasn’t just a goalie-for-goalie exchange; it was a salary cap tightrope walk, a calculated risk, and a clear signal of intent from two teams in different stages of their competitive windows. Let’s break down the transaction and assign the crucial trade grades.
🟢 Edmonton Oilers: Aggressive and All-In
Acquired: Goaltender Tristan Jarry (30, under contract through 2027-28 at a $5.375M AAV) and Forward Samuel Poulin (24, former first-round pick)
Analysis
The Oilers’ primary mission was to upgrade their goaltending consistency, a perennial issue despite the team’s potent offense. They accomplished this by landing a proven two-time All-Star in Tristan Jarry.
- The Goaltending Upgrade: Jarry, with his $5.375 million cap hit and term through 2027-28, provides the stability and pedigree the Oilers need. His .909 Save Percentage (SV%) and 2.66 Goals-Against Average (GAA) this season are a clear improvement over the numbers posted by Stuart Skinner. Jarry’s high-end performance ceiling is arguably higher, a necessity for a team with Stanley Cup aspirations. The contract term offers a secure solution in net for the next few critical years of the McDavid/Draisaitl window.
- The Cap Crunch Cost: To make the money work, Edmonton had to part with Brett Kulak, a reliable, mid-tier defenseman who posted a career-high 25 points last season. The acquisition of Spencer Stastney in a separate trade immediately addresses the hole Kulak leaves on the blueline, but Kulak’s absence will still be felt.
- The Poulin Wildcard: Acquiring former first-round pick Samuel Poulin is a high-upside swing. Though he hasn’t cracked the NHL roster consistently, a change of scenery could unlock his potential, giving the Oilers a depth forward with pedigree.
- The Risk: Jarry has had injury and playoff performance concerns in the past. If those issues resurface, the cap commitment could become an albatross. Additionally, sacrificing a 2029 second-rounder is a cost for a team that has a history of trading picks.
| Oilers Grade: | B+ |
| Justification: | They paid a high price in assets (Skinner, Kulak, a 2nd) and cap space, but they solved their most critical, immediate problem with a high-end, long-term asset. This is a move for now. |
⚫ Pittsburgh Penguins: Re-tooling and Future Focused
Acquired: Goaltender Stuart Skinner (27, pending UFA, $2.6M AAV), Defenseman Brett Kulak (31, under contract through 2025-26), and a 2029 second-round pick.
Analysis
For GM Kyle Dubas, this trade signifies a clear pivot toward re-tooling while remaining competitive in the short term. They leveraged Jarry’s strong start to the season to acquire a package that helps their cap and future.
- Cap Relief and Flexibility: Jarry’s $5.375M cap hit through 2027-28 was the most significant commitment on their goalie depth chart. Trading him frees up crucial future cap space, a vital asset as the core ages.
- The Goalie Swap: They get a younger, capable goalie in Stuart Skinner, who can serve as an immediate starter and provide stability for the rest of the season. Skinner is a pending UFA, giving the Penguins maximum flexibility to either re-sign him at a manageable number or let him walk, opening up a spot for prospects like Sergey Murashov.
- The Key Components: The value drivers for Pittsburgh are the acquisition of Brett Kulak and the 2029 second-round pick. Kulak immediately bolsters a Penguins blue line that needed depth and reliability. The 2029 second-rounder is a high-value asset, replenishing the team’s prospect cupboard and future draft capital. The late date of the pick makes it highly valuable as the Penguins’ organizational outlook may be very different by then.
- The Risk: The team now loses its proven, All-Star caliber starter for the duration of a long-term contract. While Skinner is capable, his consistency has been questioned, and he is a pending UFA. The Penguins are betting that a combination of Skinner and their developing goalie prospects will be enough.
| Penguins Grade: | A- |
| Justification: | Dubas extracted excellent value for a player who likely didn’t fit the long-term plan. They gained an immediate, useful defenseman, a high-value future pick, and a good transitional starting goalie while gaining significant future cap flexibility. This is a move for flexibility and the long-term. |
🏆 Who Won the Deal?
In a classic hockey trade where both teams address key needs, the answer depends entirely on your time horizon.
- For the 2025-2026 Stanley Cup: The Edmonton Oilers won. They immediately upgraded the most important position on a contending team, accepting the financial and asset cost because their window to win is open now.
- For the Long-Term Organizational Health: The Pittsburgh Penguins won. By turning an All-Star goalie on a big contract into an effective depth defenseman, an expiring goalie contract, and a high-value draft pick, they’ve set themselves up for a smoother, more flexible transition as their core eventually moves on.
The Penguins are the overall winner due to the sheer value and long-term flexibility they acquired. They managed to improve their blue line, get a capable temporary starter, and secure a high-value draft asset for a player they likely wanted to move to clear cap space.
However, if the Oilers hoist the Stanley Cup in the next few years, the narrative will shift entirely in their favor.
You may join my Twitter Account for more news updates, Wordle, and more game answers & hints daily.